Skip to main content

My 2025 Shampoo Research: A Journey to Healthier Hair

Hey everyone! You know how I'm always on the hunt for the "holy grail" of haircare?

Well, I recently went down a rabbit hole of shampoo ingredients and formulations with my dear friend Gemini (AI), and I've got some interesting info to share.

Understanding My Hair: The Ultimate Challenge

First, a quick refresher on my hair situation – because understanding your hair is step one to finding the right shampoo. I have what's often called "combination" hair: an oily scalp that gets greasy quickly, but the actual lengths of my hair are dry and porous. My hair has a natural wavy/curly texture, perhaps 2c/3a. On top of that, my scalp and all other skin that my hair touches can be quite sensitive and prone to breakouts.

This combination presents a real challenge! My scalp needs a shampoo that cleanses effectively to remove oil without stripping it too much. "Stripping" can actually make my scalp produce more oil – as I experienced with Olaplex 4c clarifying shampoo. Meanwhile, my dry, porous hair needs moisture and conditioning, but not so much (or not that kind) that it irritates my skin. I also struggle with tangling and strongly dislike overly harsh fragrances.

I've been using Japanese shampoos for a while and generally found them superior to many "Western" shampoos, which often felt both too stripping and too greasy. Japanese formulations tend to offer a much better balance. However, with the hard water in Los Angeles and the dry air, combined with the changes my hair has gone through with age, pregnancy, and nursing, even my go-to Japanese shampoos weren't quite enough anymore. Despite not coloring my hair, not using heat tools, and washing it infrequently, my hair remained dry, incredibly tangly, and brittle.

The hair's natural protective layer, often called the F-layer or 18-MEA layer, is a delicate coating of fatty acids that acts as hair's first line of defense. It's responsible for hair's natural shine, smoothness, and its ability to repel water, helping to prevent frizz and dryness.

When this layer is stripped away by harsh cleansers or other abuse, it's a significant problem because, unlike some other components of hair, it cannot be replenished by simply applying vegetable oils or most conditioning treatments. Once gone, it leads to a cascade of issues, and this problem is the most pronounced for dry, curly, porous hair:

  • Increased Dryness: Without its natural barrier, moisture evaporates more easily from the hair shaft, making already dry hair even drier.
  • Enhanced Frizz: The protective layer helps to smooth the cuticle. When it's missing, the cuticles lift, leading to a rougher texture and more frizz, especially in humid conditions.
  • Greater Vulnerability: The F-layer provides a protective shield against environmental damage, heat styling, and chemical treatments. Without it, hair becomes more susceptible to breakage, split ends, and overall damage, compromising its health and integrity.

Therefore, the goal of gentle but sufficient cleansing is paramount. It means choosing shampoos and cleansing methods that effectively remove dirt and product buildup without stripping away this vital protective layer, allowing my hair to retain its natural defenses and maintain its health and resilience.

I've recently made a few key changes:

  1. Switching to the gentle shampoos described in detail in this article, complemented by a clarifying shampoo once in a while.
  2. Using a new hairbrush (UNBrush) that minimizes mechanical damage during brushing.
  3. Incorporating "bond repair" treatments like Citric Acid (L'Oreal EverPure pre-shampoo) and K-18 leave-in, used along with a clarifying shampoo about once a month. This will be covered in a separate article.
  4. I'm still working through my old conditioners, but I'll be researching that topic soon.
  5. I've added a leave-in conditioner that makes my hair softer and doesn't bother my skin.

Decoding Surfactants: The Foundation of Clean

At the heart of every shampoo are surfactants, which are the ingredients that create lather and lift away dirt, oil, and product buildup. This area became the main focus of my research and a major turning point in my haircare routine.

Undesirable Ingredients: My Personal "No-Go" List

You might have heard the debate about sulfates being "terrible." It often sounds like marketing hype. I decided to try Gemini's suggestion to test out sulfate-free formulations. After a period of using them, I tried a sulfate shampoo again, and the dryness and tangles were back immediately. So it appeared that for me, milder surfactants is definitely the way to go right now. The downside? I now have to be more mindful of product buildup and incorporate clarifying shampoos. For how my hair looks and feels, it's absolutely worth it.

Harsh Sulfates (e.g., Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (SLS), Sodium Coco-Sulfate (SCS)): These are classic, very efficient cleansers, but, they say, they have the potential to cause cuticle damage over time and can be very stripping. In my personal experience, this felt true. For sensitive scalps, it often leads to irritation. Even if a product claims "natural" sulfates (like SCS), their chemical harshness can remain.

Petrolatum and Mineral Oils: These are a no-go for me in anything except a foot cream due to personal preference.

Excessive Alcohol: Sometimes used as a solvent or for quick-drying, but in higher concentrations, it can be drying or irritating for the scalp.

Certain Polyquaterniums (e.g., Polyquaternium-7, -10) / Cocamide MEA: These are conditioning agents and foam boosters. However, in higher amounts, especially for an oily scalp, they can contribute to residue and buildup, even with thorough rinsing. I'm still learning how true this is and if those risks outweigh the benefits in every formulation, but that's what Gemini suggested to watch out for.

Overly High Concentrations of Fragrance/Essential Oils: While I personally tolerate natural fragrances well unless they're super concentrated, for truly sensitive skin, any added scent is a potential irritant.

Overly High Concentrations of Oils and Heavy Conditioners: Hello itchy scalp and other skin, flat hair and acne all over.

It is important to note, that true soap is actually sulfate-free, but it is harsher that sulfates.

Superstar Cleansing Ingredients: 

Instead of strong cleansers, the new recommended shampoos feature these mild yet effective surfactants:

Sodium Cocoyl Isethionate (SCI): Derived from coconut oil, this is a very mild surfactant. It creates a creamy, luxurious lather that cleanses thoroughly without stripping. Gemini says, It's truly a superstar cleanser!

Sodium Methyl Cocoyl Taurate: Another excellent, gentle surfactant. It offers a great clean and is very kind to the scalp.

Sodium Cocoyl Glycinate: An incredibly mild, amino acid-based surfactant that makes the cleansing experience even softer and more skin-friendly.

Decyl Glucoside / Lauryl Glucoside: These are also very gentle, plant-derived surfactants often used in "natural" or sensitive-skin formulations.

Beyond Clean: The Power of Conditioning and Actives

Of course shampoos aren't just about cleaning; they're also about setting the stage for healthy hair. This is where advanced conditioning agents and beneficial "actives" come into play.

Superstar Conditioning & Active Ingredients:

  • Niacinamide (Vitamin B3): Gamini says it's "a true hero!" This helps to balance oil production on the scalp (should be great for my oily scalp), reduces inflammation, and strengthens the skin's barrier. It's a fantastic all-rounder for scalp health. I actually bought a jar of Niacinamide powder and I'll be experimenting with mixing it into various products. I've already noticed increased skin hydration and density with it.
  • Ceramides (e.g., Ceramide NG): These are like the "mortar" between the "bricks" of hair cuticles and scalp skin. They help repair damage, strengthen the hair's natural barrier, and significantly improve moisture retention – absolutely vital for dry, porous hair.
  • Hydrolyzed Proteins (e.g., Hydrolyzed Rice Protein, Soy Protein, Keratin, Collagen): These are proteins broken down into smaller pieces so they can penetrate and strengthen the hair shaft, adding moisture, improving elasticity, and helping repair damage in porous hair.
  • Hyaluronic Acid (various forms): Just like in skincare, this powerhouse humectant draws and holds moisture, providing deep hydration to dry hair.
  • Rich Butters & Oils (e.g., Shea Butter, Cocoa Butter, Babassu Oil, Avocado Oil, Squalane): These emollients provide intense nourishment and softness, smoothing the hair cuticle and reducing frizz. The trick here is balancing their richness so they condition well without weighing down an oily scalp.
  • Fermented Ingredients (e.g., Rice Ferments): These extracts, often from fermented rice, are gaining popularity for their ability to strengthen hair, add shine, and provide beneficial nutrients to the scalp.
  • Panthenol (Pro-Vitamin B5): A classic moisturizing and strengthening vitamin for hair.
  • Behentrimonium Methosulfate & Fatty Alcohols (e.g., Cetearyl Alcohol, Brassica Alcohol): These are powerful conditioning and detangling ingredients often found in conditioners. When included in a shampoo, they significantly boost its conditioning prowess, providing great slip and softness right from the wash stage.

The Best of the Bunch: Our Top Picks

After reviewing numerous ingredient lists with Gemini, here are the shampoos that got the highest rating and why they stand out as great modern haircare for my hair type:

  • Japanese Off&Relax Night Repair (Rated 4.8/5): 
This liquid shampoo featured Sodium Methyl Cocoyl Taurate and Lauryl Hydroxysultaine for an incredibly mild and effective cleanse. What truly made it shine was its deep hydration from multiple forms of Hyaluronic Acid and Hydrolyzed Soy Protein, plus an impressive array of fermented rice extracts, CoQ10, and various other plant extracts. This blend ensures it cleanses my oily scalp gently while providing serious moisture and nourishment to my dry, porous lengths. The only minor caveat was a generic "Fragrance" and "Alcohol" low on the list.
  • Kitsch Rice Water Shampoo Bar (Rated 4.9/5):
This bar combined the ultimate mild cleansing duo: Sodium Cocoyl Isethionate and Sodium Methyl Cocoyl Taurate. It also packed a punch with conditioning from Hydrogenated Castor Oil, Guar Hydroxypropyltrimonium Chloride, and crucially, Hydrolyzed Rice Protein for strengthening. This bar truly hit all the marks for gentle, effective cleansing and targeted conditioning without any known irritants for my hair type, according to Gemini, I still need to try it.
  • Ethique Gentle Shampoo Bar (Rated 4.8/5):
This bar featured Sodium Cocoyl Isethionate and Sodium Cocoyl Glycinate for an incredibly gentle cleanse, combined with an intense conditioning complex: Cocoa Butter, Babassu Oil, Behentrimonium Methosulfate, Brassica Alcohol, and Guar Hydroxypropyltrimonium Chloride. This heavy-hitting conditioning profile is phenomenal for dry, porous hair, providing amazing slip and softness. It is also free of added fragrance, making it a great choice for sensitive scalps, though its richness is something to monitor to ensure it's not too much for an oily scalp over time, AI said.
  • Japanese Off&Relax Moisture (Rated 4.0/5) (This is the one I already got):
This shampoo featured a very mild cleansing base including Sodium Methyl Cocoyl Taurate, Sodium Cocoyl Alaninate, and Lauryl Hydroxysultaine, combined with beneficial fermented rice ingredients. It also included Cocamide Methyl MEA and Polyquaternium-10, which could potentially contribute to minimal buildup for an oily scalp, though my thorough rinsing technique helps mitigate this. Overall, a great balance of mild cleansing and beneficial actives.
  • Japanese Botanist Smooth (Rated 3.5/5):
This shampoo stood out for its impressive conditioning and strengthening complex, including Hydrolyzed Hyaluronic Acid, Hydrolyzed Vegetable Protein, Hydrolyzed Collagen, Hydrolyzed Keratin, and Ceramides. These ingredients are fantastic for dry, porous hair. The cleansing base was generally mild. However, Gemini says that the presence of Alcohol and Fragrance were notable concerns for my sensitive scalp, and the sheer number of conditioning agents could potentially contribute to buildup. Alcohol is pretty low on the list so I doubt it is more than 1%. Despite these caveats, the promise of such strong repair and hydration for my lengths makes me want to give it a cautious try.

Still Have to Do the Trial and Error

As always, your individual hair type and preferences might not perfectly align with broad scientific research or general recommendations. Personalized trial and error, guided by an understanding of ingredient lists, is the way to go.



Comments